The end-of-life Centres
Eligibility Criteria
Updated
“These are not criteria plucked out of the blue by the centres themselves. They are necessary to comply with Swiss Law and the guidelines of the Swiss Professional Institutions”
The end-of-life centres do not really have their own criteria, as such. They must, however, operate within the laws and guidelines of the various Swiss authorities and they are obviously keen to do so.
The Swiss law itself is quite straightforward.
Most people know that Assisted Dying is legal in Switzerland. Many also know that the Swiss accept foreigners for the purpose of receiving a Voluntary Assisted Death (VAD). Several have learned, correctly, that it is the only country in the world which is prepared to do so.
From there on, myths can get started. You cannot, for example, just turn up and expect someone to help you to kill yourself. The are no self-help clinics where, for a big fee, you can just walk in and not come out alive. Swiss law is relatively permissive but it is certainly no pushover. Prosecutions do happen and there is a continuing body of opposition to the whole concept of “suicide tourism”.
The potential offence, of course, is not suicide. Nor is it attempted suicide. Both are legal in Switzerland – as they are elsewhere throughout the developed world, including America and the UK. The offence would simply be “assisting a suicide”.
Initially, the Swiss law seems startlingly clear. No offence will have been committed if the patient had full mental capacity, if they carried out the final act themselves and if the motivations of any helper were “altruistic”. However, there is then a second strand to the Swiss law which adds a bit more detail. This is remarkably similar to the “guidance” as issued by the Director of Public Prosecutions in the UK. Specifically, the patient must have a “well-reflected” desire to end their life, they need to be free from any external pressure to do so, they must be suffering from unendurable pain or an incurable problem – and possibilities for therapeutic or palliative alternatives must have been explored.
This, then, is the legal framework under which the individual clinics (who prefer to be called Voluntary Assisted Dying providers) must make their own decisions upon which applicants might, or might not, satisfy the eligibility test. In doing so, they are seeking simply to protect themselves from any potential legal action. Understandably, the four separate VAD providers come to different conclusions about where they should draw the line.
“Full mental capacity”
When the Swiss talk about “full mental capacity”, they mean that you must be fully aware of the decisions you are taking. You must appreciate the impact they will have. And you must fully appreciate the context in which you will be taking such a decision.
In the case of a relatively straightforward application for a VAD this “full mental capacity” can usually be taken for granted – well, initially at least. All applications will need to be accompanied by a copy of your full and recent medical records. If these show any indication that mental capacity could be an issue, then the VAD provider will need additional re-assurance that this is not going to become a major barrier. Their concern will be triggered if there has been any recent mental illness diagnosis. Even if you have simply been prescribed pills for depression, the provider will want such re-assurance.
That is not to say that a mental illness would automatically disqualify you from a VAD, simply that an additional level of specialist opinion will be required. This will need to be requested from a psychiatrist, neurologist or geriatrician.
The VAD providers vary between themselves upon the question of how much re-assurance should be provided. Dignitas, for example, usually insist upon one professional opinion from your own country. The others may show a greater degree of flexibility and be satisfied with one supportive report from a Swiss doctor. In all cases, whether the “mental capacity” issue has been raised or not, the provider will require a second, specific, medical opinion immediately before the date of your VAD itself.

DIGNITAS
“Anyone suffering from a serious illness, an intolerable impairment, uncontrollable pain or a long-lasting and/or a recurring mental illness, who wants voluntarily to put an end to their life and suffering can, as a member of DIGNITAS, request the Association to help them with accompanied suicide”
That, taken from the Dignitas brochure, is commendably crisp and clear. Note that there is no mention of “death within six months”. Dignitas then add further words to clarify their view of applicants with a mental illness or whose problems of old age have simply made life as a whole too arduous :
“Contrary to a widely-held opinion, people suffering from mental health problems normally have sufficient capacity of discernment to decide whether they would like to continue living or end their life. Therefore, and as a general rule, they are entitled to ask for an accompanied suicide and receive assistance just as much as people suffering from physical health problems, in order to avoid the high risk of failure. The same applies to otherwise-healthy people who wish to end their life because they feel that it has become too arduous for them due to problems of old age. There are no rational reasons to patronise these people through paternalism”.
At a formal level, the number of people who “fail” the assessment by Dignitas and its co-operating physicians appears to be very small – fewer than 10% in 2025. However, that is because of the thorough advice and guidance available from Dignitas itself, substantially through its website, prior to an application being made. Few people go through the detail of making an application if they believe they are not going to succeed. Essentially, a middle-aged person who is simply going through a bad patch in their lives for emotional or financial reasons is unlikely to be successful.
In addition to the criteria mentioned above, an applicant for a physician-supported assisted suicide must also be over eighteen, a member of Dignitas, of “sound judgement” and also “possesses a minimum level of physical mobility (sufficient to administer the drug)”. This latter point is emphasised with the words:
“In every case, for legal reasons, the patient must be able to undertake the last act – that is to swallow, to administer via the gastric tube or to open the valve of the intravenous access tube himself or herself. If this is not possible DIGNITAS is unfortunately unable to help.”
A patient will also need a minimal level of communication ability, sufficient to indicate that he or she is aware of the proposed course of action and is in agreement with it.

LIFECIRCLE
Lifecircle was the main alternative to Dignitas until November 2022. In that month, Lifecircle closed its books to new members. It is still operational (in 2025 it handled about a dozen AVDs) but people starting their search for the first time should not consider Lifecircle.
“There are diseases which are not curable with all medical procedures and which sometimes cannot be stopped in their progression. People who suffer from such an illness, can be severely disabled and in need of nursing care over a long period of time. In this situation, some people do not want to continue to bear their fate because they see no sense in a life in complete dependence and without their own activity. Some people feel the need to be nursed as not dignified, they do not want to be wrapped and washed like an infant. Some diseases cause pains that can be made bearable only with such high doses of morphine or sedatives that the patient is unconscious. Those who do not accept to be nursed without hope of improvement may be eligible for Assisted Voluntary Death (AVD)”.
This broader definition gave Lifecircle a wider degree of discretion. They would sometimes accept a patient, frequently with a neurodegenerative such as Parkinson’s or early-stage Dementia, that would have found it more difficult to get a green light with Dignitas.
Lifecircle remains helpfully clear about the conditions for which it is willing to offer an AVD. Conditions such as dementia, multiple sclerosis, motor neurone disease and quadriplegia are specifically mentioned as being eligible for AVD.
However, the closure of Lifecircle’s membership in 2022 means that they now handle only a small (and diminishing) number of AVDs each year. So unless you happen to be a member of long-standing you can delete Lifecircle from your list of options. Which it a pity. They are very good indeed.

PEGASOS
“Pegasos believes that it is the human right of every rational adult of sound mind, regardless of state of health, to choose the manner and the timing of their death.”
So this is the most all-encompassing of the lot. It does, however, raise a number of questions. Some, not all, of these are answered on the Pegasos website.
Does your family need to know?
Pegasos says it is
“… strongly of the opinion that you should inform your family at some point, even if you know that they will not be supportive.”
Does Pegasos help “well” people to die?
“Pegasos believes that for a person to be in the headspace of considering ending their lives, their quality of life must be qualitatively poor. Pegasos accepts that some people who are not technically ‘sick’ may want to apply for a Voluntary Assisted Death, But this does not mean the person is ‘well’. Professor David Goodall* was one of these people. He was not sick but his eyesight was failing him, as was his mobility. Old age is rarely kind. The decision to end one’s life is an intensely personal one. Pegasos makes every effort to understand fully the unique circumstances of everyone who makes contact with us.”
* It was David Goodall who inspired the founding of Pegasos in 2019. He flew from Australia to receive a voluntary assisted death from Lifecircle, with Ruedi Habegger handling his case. He was 103 and not suffering from any ailments, other than those that should normally be expected in a 103-year-old.
With such a wide net of eligibility, it is worth asking what kind of patient might not be accepted. Imagine, for example, a family man in his fifties. He is reasonably fit but is suicidal because he can see no way out of his financial difficulties. Would Pegasos accept an application from him ? It is difficult to see that they would be right to say Yes. Presumably his family would prefer him to be bankrupt but alive, with some remaining earning-power ? Better that than dead having left an insolvent estate. A man taking his own life in those circumstances is, on the face of things, simply abdicating his responsibilities. Would Pegasos really want to be a party to such selfishness ?
This point was covered in some detail during my talks with Ruedi Habegger and his team, most recently in October 2026. In summary, the Pegasos decision upon a case such as the above would depend very heavily upon the applicant’s age, upon the length of time that the problem had existed and upon the prospect for getting over it in the future. In the specific case above, the answer would be No.
ATHANASIOS and PHOENIX CARE
2025 saw the arrival of two new AVD providers – Athanasios in April and Phoenix Care in July. By the end of the year, Athanasios is estimated to have completed 65 AVDs and Phoenix Care approximately 40. Both of these new providers have positioned themselves between Dignitas and Pegasos and each one is seeking to replicate the “all round care” approach formerly adopted by Lifecircle. This website now carries separate review pages upon each one.
SUMMARY SO FAR
At this point, based on the stated criteria alone, the conclusion seems pretty clear. If you are suffering from a well-understood illness such as cancer or MND which is going to prove fatal or if is causing great pain or is “unendurable” then your choice might well be Dignitas. Their experience, thoroughness and dedication to a systematic process mean that you can put your trust in their ability to get the outcome you want.
However, if your illness may not be fatal or if there are other, more subtle, reasons why you want to end your life then your choice is likely to be between Athanasios, Phoenix and Pegasos.
Many people who choose Pegasos, Phoenix or Athanasios, do so because they prefer to deliver the fatal dose by means of a cannula in a vein rather than an unpleasant-tasting drink in the mouth. The effectiveness is also faster by cannula.
On the face of things, you may not even need to be clinically ill at all to seek the services of Pegasos. However, your reasons must have taken into account your responsibilities to others and must have a strong and permanent strand of logic behind them.
So, if you can imagine a spectrum of eligibility with Dignitas at one end and Pegasos at the other, you would find Athanasios and Phoenix somewhere in between but a bit closer to Pegasos.
As. you might suspect, the choice is not quite that simple. Please read the summaries of our visits to the various centres before making any decision.
Read Next Section >