< Back to News

A new attempt to change the law in England

Following the defeats this summer of the Assisted Dying Bills in Scotland and in England & Wales, a new change is now being suggested.    Much smaller in scale, this would involve a simple amendment to the Suicide Act of 1961 to decriminalise people who help others to receive a voluntary assisted death in Switzerland.   Specifically, it would amend Section 2 of the Act by adding an exemption clause in the words “save only that it shall not be unlawful to assist persons already contractually bound to a registered Swiss assisted dying clinic”.

This suggestion has been made by Dr Margaret Branthwaite, a retired consultant medical practitioner, barrister and coroner.   It forms the basis of a letter to five authorities regulating health care professionals in the UK, including the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges and the General Medical Council.

At the moment many British patients of the Swiss clinics have to travel alone.   They worry that any accompaniment by a friend or family member might subsequently involve a criminal investigation or a challenge to their Will.   On this website we have consistently argued that the simple act of accompaniment cannot be presented as “assisting a suicide”.   However, if any physical help or paperwork is handled by the helper then the risk becomes much higher.   The proposed change would remove that.   As a fall-back, Dr Branthwaite has also suggested that the Director of Public Prosecution could amend the current guidelines on when to prosecute.

The legal change would require Parliamentary approval.   That is to say it would require a debate and the full level of legislative process.   There are no short cuts available.   Further, on such an issue, no government help should be expected.   Therefore it would require a Private Member’s initiative to get it started.   This need not, however, be presented by one of the winners of the annual ballot for Private Members’ Bills.   In a lesser-noticed procedure, any MP at any time can introduce a Bill through something called the “Ten Minute Rule”.   Such Bills usually get little further than their first ten minutes in the House of Commons but one or two each year do make it through to the Statute Book.   A Bill on the lines proposed is not exactly earth-shattering in its scope and could perhaps, even in the present climate, be a way to solve the present problems – which are, actually increasingly acute.

The change proposed would place a responsibility on health care professionals to recognise and respond to the higher than average levels of unassisted suicide among patients with severe or intractable illnesses.    It would also help to remove the aura of secrecy and fear of possible criminality which is so often apparent during discussions of assisted dying.